If your bathtub is looking worn, stained, or outdated, you might think your only option is a full replacement. However, bathtub refinishing—also called reglazing or resurfacing—is a cost-effective alternative that can make your tub look like new again. Unfortunately, plenty of myths surround this process, and they can keep homeowners from making informed decisions.

Whether you're weighing your options or already searching for a trusted bathtub refinishing company, it's important to separate fact from fiction. Let's take a moment to clear up some of the most common misconceptions about bathtub refinishing, so you can feel confident in choosing the right solution for your home.

Misconception 1: Refinishing Is Just a Temporary Fix

Some people assume refinishing is only a quick cosmetic solution that won’t last. In reality, a professionally refinished bathtub can offer long-term results when done properly. According to This Old House, reglazing offers a longer lifespan of 15 to 20 years, especially when the surface is prepped correctly and maintained with care. That longevity is comparable to lower-end replacement tubs, without the demolition or high costs. Choosing a reputable bathtub refinishing company will make a significant difference in the results and durability of the finish.

Misconception 2: Replacing Is Always Better Than Refinishing

While there are times when replacement is necessary, like in the case of severe structural damage, refinishing is often the better option for bathtubs that are simply worn or discolored. Refinishing is especially appealing if you're happy with the size and layout of your current tub. A skilled technician can repair chips, cracks, and stains, giving your bathtub a factory-new appearance without the mess and expense of replacing the whole fixture.

Homeowners often don’t realize how invasive a full bathtub replacement can be. You’ll likely need plumbing work, tile repair, and maybe even floor patching. That’s a lot of cost and disruption just to swap out a tub.

Misconception 3: You Can DIY It and Get the Same Results

DIY kits for bathtub refinishing are widely available, but they rarely produce professional results. These kits often use lower-quality materials and don’t include the industrial-grade bonding agents or spray equipment used by professionals. As a result, the finish may peel or chip within months, and you’ll have to redo the entire process—or hire a pro to fix the damage.

Hiring an experienced bathtub refinishing company ensures that proper ventilation, surface preparation, and curing times are followed. These steps are critical for achieving a durable, high-gloss finish that stands up to daily use.

Misconception 4: It’s Only for Old or Damaged Tubs

Many people think refinishing is just a way to revive old, damaged bathtubs. While that’s certainly true, it’s also a smart option for updating the look of perfectly functional tubs. If your bathroom’s color scheme is outdated, refinishing allows you to change the color of your tub without replacing it. A professional bathtub refinishing company can give you a sleek white finish or a trendy shade to match your new tile, paint, or design theme.

Refinishing also works for homeowners flipping properties or updating rental units on a budget—it provides the look of a full renovation for a fraction of the cost. Even newly installed tubs that were scratched during construction or don’t quite match the final design can benefit from refinishing. It’s a versatile solution that isn’t just about damage control—it’s about customization and visual harmony. A reputable bathtub refinishing company can tailor the finish to suit your style goals, making it a practical choice for both aesthetic upgrades and functional improvements.

Misconception 5: Refinished Tubs Always Look Painted

A common concern is that refinished tubs will look obviously painted or feel rough to the touch. When done correctly, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Professional refinishing includes thorough sanding, bonding, and spraying using specialized equipment. The result is a smooth, glass-like surface that mimics the look and feel of a brand-new tub. Most people wouldn’t be able to tell the difference between a new tub and a refinished one, especially when the job is completed by a top-tier bathtub refinishing company.

In fact, one of the most common compliments a professional refinishing contractor receives is how “new” the tub looks and feels. The high-gloss finish, seamless application, and color uniformity achieved through professional methods are virtually impossible to replicate with a brush or roller. This is why homeowners, landlords, and even hotels trust a bathtub refinishing company to deliver results that elevate the entire look of a bathroom.

Misconception 6: It’s Not Safe or Eco-Friendly

Another misconception is that bathtub refinishing uses toxic chemicals or poses risks to your health. While it’s true that refinishing products contain strong compounds, professional technicians follow strict safety guidelines—including proper ventilation and personal protective equipment—to minimize exposure.

Additionally, refinishing is actually more eco-friendly than replacing. Instead of sending a large piece of cast iron, steel, or acrylic to a landfill, you’re reusing what you already have. This helps conserve materials and reduces your environmental footprint.

Many modern refinishing products are also formulated to meet environmental regulations, including low-VOC (volatile organic compound) standards. This means they produce fewer harmful emissions during application and curing. When applied by a trained professional, these environmentally sustainable coatings not only reduce environmental impact but also contribute to healthier indoor air quality during and after the refinishing process. If sustainability is important to you, working with a responsible bathtub refinishing company is a smart choice.

Misconception 7: It’s Not Worth the Cost

Because reglazing typically costs more than a DIY kit and sometimes approaches the lower range of replacement prices, some people believe it's not worth the money. But this overlooks the value of a well-done professional job. While reglazing may cost you more than a cheap DIY attempt, it can provide years of use when done properly. That’s a serious return on investment, especially when compared to the cost and time of a full remodel.

When you consider the labor, demolition, and plumbing changes involved in replacement, refinishing continues to become a clear value winner. It’s also a great way to add value to your home ahead of a sale, without undertaking a major renovation. Plus, partnering with a trusted bathtub refinishing company means you’re investing in quality workmanship, proven materials, and a finish that holds up to daily wear. Rather than dealing with recurring issues like peeling or discoloration from budget options, you get long-lasting results that enhance both the appearance and function of your bathroom. That peace of mind and professional durability more than justify the upfront cost.

Don’t let misinformation keep you from making a practical decision. Bathtub refinishing is a smart, affordable, and lasting way to update your bathroom. Whether your tub is chipped, stained, or just the wrong color, working with a reliable bathtub refinishing company can transform your space without the stress of full replacement. With professional techniques, proper materials, and the right care, refinishing offers a beautiful result that can last for decades. Before you start tearing out your tub, consider how much you could save—and how good your bathroom could look—with a high-quality refinish provided by the professionals at Bath Magic. Give us a call today to get started with a free estimate on your next refinishing project!